Sunday, 20 January 2008

Timeline - where Archaeology meets History.

communityarchaeology wiki / Timeline York Plus Newsletter no 1
Yesterday I went to a fascinating meeting in York which showed me how the boundaries of archaeology are being pressed ever-outwards. This is presumably more than a mere marketing ploy.

I used to semi-believe the stereotype "Historians study documents; Archeologists study artefacts", but its validity was denied by those present representing the Council for British Archaeology.

The meeting of Timeline York Plus was attended by some 20 representative history groups and others from the York area. These included the following (edited from a previous Timeline newsletter):

N.B.: This blog still being edited.

(Timeline York Plus is an informal association of historical and archaeological societies in the area of greater York, providing a forum for the exchange of news and views.)

  • Acomb Local History Group

This group meets on the second Wednesday of each month except August. They cover a very wide range and are very well attended. The subject matter varies considerably; one of the most successful recently was on the history of Boyes Store.
  • Bishopthorpe Local History Group

This group is working together with the Bishopthorpe Millennium Trust to develop the Pinfold Area producing ceramic plaques on the history of Bishopthorpe. Other projects are ongoing.
  • Derwent Archaeology Group (DAG)

Derwent Archaeology Group was formerly part of Dunnington through the Ages. Its aims and objectives remain the same i.e. to investigate the history and settlement of the Derwent Ward. To date we have carried out resistivity surveys on two sites which we believe indicate the presence of Roman roads. We aim to confirm these with “digs” in the late autumn. Cropping permitting, we also hope to investigate a possible iron age site located close to Dunnington.
  • Dringhouses Local History Group

The history of Dringhouses extends back at least 2000 years, with evidence of Roman occupation, a medieval village, the brick making industry, the turnpike road, grand Victorian properties, the church and school etc. The adjacent Knavesmire has not only the history of the racecourse but also a former Royal Observer Corps building and the Wood, originally planted in the 18th century.

Dringhouses Local History Group coordinates research and information about all this and more! The Group has a programme of talks and visits to places of local interest and always welcomes photographs and memories of Dringhouses past and present. For further information please contact York 706384.

  • Dunnington Through the Ages

Meetings are on the 1st Thursday each month. For further information, contact 01904 488433 or 01904 488229.

  • Friends of Hagg Wood

The Friends of Hagg Wood celebrated their 10th anniversary as a community group in 2006. They have recently been awarded a LHI grant for a historical survey of the wood and its environs to be undertaken by Stephen Moorhouse, a well known landscape historian. He will be giving a talk on Wednesday 11th October 2006 entitled “Hagg Wood in its Historical Context”, describing how he will approach the LHI landscape history project. It will be held in Dunnington Reading Room, in the centre of the village, at 8 p.m. All welcome. Free for members and £1.50p for non-members.

  • Friends of Hobb Moor

Plans for archaeological work on Hob Moor include two projects. The first will consist of investigations to try to determine the site of the medieval water mill which was situated in the north-east corner and for which there is documentary evidence from the 16th and 17th centuries. The second project will attempt to determine the age of the ancient causeway which crosses the original common area from south-west to north-east. Anyone interested in these projects can contact the Friends of Hob Moor on York 703970.


  • Forest and Hopgrove Local History Group

Our members live in the Stockton on the Forest and Hopgrove areas of York. To contact us please speak or write to either:
Terry Briggs: 46 Kingsmoor Road, Stockton on the Forest, YO32 9TY (Tel. 01904 400013) or Steve Burton: 98, the Village, Stockton on the Forest, YO32 9UW (Tel. 01904 400066)

  • Haxby Local History Group

Pauline Briggs prepared a display, to mark the 90th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme, which was on display in the local library in June and July. This was also taken to the Haxby Carnival on July 8th and displayed along with much other material in a marquee. There was a gratifying amount of interest: we were busy all afternoon and some useful information came to light. Also, the “Flying Ducks”, the Haxby Youth Theatre, gave a performance of the Haxby Sword Dance; they hope, sometime in the future, to be able to revive the Plough Stotts Plays (these were apparently performed by the ploughboys – other villages in the area also have these plays). The word “Stott” is defined in the Annandale Concise Dictionary of 1896 as a Scots word meaning young bullock or steer!

  • Poppleton History Society

The archaeological group carried out a geophysical survey of the scheduled ancient monument site near St. Everilda’s church over a period of two weekends during June & July 2006. The objectives were to confirm the initial findings of Channel 4 Time Team, that indicated the existence of a Tudor manor and to carry out an initial survey of the platform of the moated site. The results were encouraging and prompt further research using other geophysical techniques. A report on the activity will be sent to English Heritage.

The History Society will resume its monthly schedule of speakers’ events in the autumn.

For further details contact 01904 338610.

  • South Ainsty Archaeological Society (SAAS)

The group formed in 2004 to promote interest in the archaeology and local history of the area roughly southwest of York within a triangle bounded by the A64 and the rivers Ouse and Wharfe.

Currently our energies are focused on the excavations at the Knights Templar field in Copmanthorpe which is the subject of a dig co-ordinated by professional archaeologists Chris Fenton-Thomas (of ‘On Site Archaeology’) and Catrina Appleby (our Chairperson). We are as confident as we can be from our interpretation of old documents and aerial photos that the area under excavation is the site of the order’s preceptory which would have functioned as a large farm. However, the initial purpose of the dig is to establish if this area is indeed the site. We hope to find some evidence of stone buildings, ditches, enclosures and (Medieval) rubbish pits.

Our normal programme includes lectures, meetings and visits; and we are also keen to develop activities to complement our archaeological work, especially a project in oral history.For more details contact: Tel. 01904 705478 or 744263.

Stop Press: The excavations over the weekend of 15/17 September unearthed a quantity of medieval tile, pottery and glazed floor tiles in the general area of the dig. So far, there have been no specific finds to report but we wait for later developments.



  • Stillingfleet Chroniclers


We are a small group with just 6 members, nevertheless we have applied for an Awards for All grant to buy equipment to help with the recording and storage of Stillingfleet's history.

Two public events were held this year: an open day in March and a film show of old pictures in April. Both were a great success so it has been decided to hold another event next Spring on the theme of "Stillingfleet in World War II".

We will continue to collect as much information as possible on Stillingfleet and have already acquired a full set of census returns, parish records from 1700 to present day, school registers, monumental inscriptions from both churchyard and cemetery and lots of old photographs, particularly ones of the schoolchildren through the ages. We have found two old maps of the village, one for 1751 and one for 1810 and would like to find the missing Tithe Map for the village. There is also a village plan for 1788 held by the Minster Library but that too has gone astray. We are searching the newspapers in Selby Library for mentions of the village but so far have found very little.

Hopefully if/when we get our Lottery Grant, the new equipment will entice some new members and eventually lead to maybe a village website and perhaps a book.


  • Strensall Local History Group

Progress has been made in the investigations into the history of Strensall Tannery, and a new subject of research has commenced. The Tannery was started around 1805. Why a tannery was established specifically in Strensall is not certain, but the fact that it was built next to the Foss Navigation (first opened in 1796) with its easy access to York and beyond may have been the deciding factor. Our Family History sub-group has looked at the Strensall census returns for 1841 onwards and found that most of the tannery workers were born outside the village. Were they agricultural labourers looking for work? The new subject of research concerns an area north of Strensall stretching from Lilling Green Roman period farm (?) to the site of a mill on the River Foss near to Sheriff Hutton Bridge. This area is all that is left of the ancient Wapentake of Bolesford. From the limited amount of field observations and studies of old maps, we conclude that Bolesford has a lot of history that needs "unlocking".

Fulford Battlefield Project - Hungate Young Archaeologists - New Earswick Group – Newton-on-Derwent Local History Society - Stamford Bridge Community Archaeology - Tang Hall Local History Group - Wiggington History Group. We hope to include the news from these groups in future editions.

Tuesday, 15 January 2008

Pearsonian Peregrinations

This blog will include random thoughts linked one way or another - often at several steps removed - with the person and/or ideas of Karl Pearson - universally recognised as 'KP', and one of the few persons generally defined by just two initials. ('GBS' is 50% weaker.)

'Peregrination' means not just a rambling (this was the meaning I ascribed to it - rambling is a mode of talking as well as a way of walking: thus giving a completely new meaning to the "Ramblers Association"). Peregrination is also a journey, indeed even a pilgrimage. All three meanings - rambling, journey, pilgrimage - are germane to the way my interest in KP has developed.

Pearson's interests ranged far and wide, especially in his younger years (chaptered as "Lehrjahre of a Poetic Wrangler" in Porter's biography of KP, reflecting KP's chapter "Lehrjahre and Wanderjahre" in his own biography of Galton). Galton wandered further, wider and earlier than Pearson, but KP was no slouch for his day. Maybe he wanted to get away from UK domesticity at Cambridge and Hampstead? (His uncle however was in India in 1859 - not that it did him much good, as he died at sea on his way home - not many people know this" - see his gravestone at Crambe.)

Pearson's intellectual Wanderungen created problems and adventures for this ardent member of the KPFC (Karl Pearson Fan Club), as it leads to such a divergent range of materials - medieval theology, German folk-theatre, art, epistemology, etc.., etc.. It is remarkable in all this how the discourse of commentators so often slips naturally into germanics -

Levine's Dying to Know has a chapter on Pearson ("Karl Pearson and the Romance of Science"), as does Herbert's Victorian Relativity ("Karl Pearson and the Human Form Divine"). (I have not yet seen the latter, other than at GoogleBooks.)

Levine (2002, p13) reports how his book's "animus ... changed as it lived through at least a decade of reflection." Starting life as a "critique ... of the impossible scientific ideal of disinterested scientific knowledge", it ended discontented at today's complacency, which refuses to accept "not only the possibility of objectivity but of the good faith of quests for it .... '(O)bjectivity' in much academic discourse has become a curse word ..."

I was in the USA recently, and was fortunate enough to meet up with Levine. It is interesting how professors of literature, germanics and women's studies all include Pearson within their remit.

Wednesday, 26 December 2007

BadSums

I'm planning to start a BadSums blog. This will highlight the use of maths + numeracy in the media, with focus upon things that are wrong/funny/interesting/important or otherwise notable. In some ways it will mimic Ben Goldacre's Bad science site - 'cos all good science involves maths anyway, so bad scienceprobably involves bad maths or bad sums.



Ben himself calls this “an uber-participatory quack-busting pseudoscience-fighting media-monitoring comedy community evil empire … (plus) good fun”, which I could not begin to argue with.
http://www.badscience.net/?p=446


Watch this space!

Tuesday, 20 November 2007

HMRC cock-up: 25 million missing records

Quite apart from the failure of HMRC, I feel the media treatment has been pretty shoddy. There was 20 minutes of shock-horror stuff on 'PM' today, and the Secretary to the treasury was there - but not once was anyone asked Was the data encrypted? If not, why not? Was it passworded? If so, who decided on the password? Who knew it? and how was the password conveyed from A to B?

Why did the BBC not ask these relevant questions?

And why was the data being transferred anyway? What was it the audit commisiion was doing that meant they needed to know my bank account details, birthdate and other personal data? When we hand these data over, it is often udner duress but for specific purposes only.

Tuesday, 30 October 2007

Immigration Statistics Anxiety: how 800,000 becomes 1,100,000

Am I the only one who’s befuddled by this immigration debate?

It seems that 800,000 should have been 1,100,000 and the Labour Force Survey is implicated.

Where should I look to find out more?

(Is it a case of errors in a residual? This is so often the curse of apparently very large and whimsical errors, but may not be the culprit in this case.)

In my naïve way, I can’t see why the aggregate figures can’t just be obtained by checking people as they come in and go out. (We are all checked, after all!)

The important things seem to be age/sex/birthplace/nationality, and maybe what the hell are you doing here and where are you going? (as it’s the local figures which are really important for policy terms)

Should the Radical Stats ImmigrationWatch Watch team be issuing a press release which I and the average Daily Mail reader can understand?

My main worry is that Immigration Anxiety and every other sort of Anxiety is rapidly becoming a Statistics Anxiety.

Sunday, 28 October 2007

Free entry to museums: problems from supply-driven economics

We're all in favour of making education affordable. But supply-side initiatives have their problems. Apart from the general ones (over-supply, bad faith etc), in museums there are two important distributive effects:

1. The 'National' museums to which free admission is granted tend to be in London and the South-East, thus benefiting Southerners and tourists. (Please don't think I've got anything against either .....)

2. Subsidising National museums makes it very difficult for local museums & others that do not have this subsidy.


An alternative subsidy could be: ..... Let EVERYONE have vouchers worth £X that can be used for entry to ANY museum. This would lead to more of a level-playing field.
==============


A belated response ......

We're all in favour of making education affordable. But supply-side initiatives have their problems. Apart from the general ones (over-supply, bad faith etc), in museums there are two important distributive effects:

1. The 'National' museums to which free admission is granted tend to be in London and the South-East, thus benefiting Southerners and tourists. (Please don't think I've got anything against either .....)

2. Subsidising National museums makes it very difficult for local museums & others that do not have this subsidy.


An alternative subsidy could be: ..... Let EVERYONE have vouchers worth £X that can be used for entry to ANY museum. This would lead to more of a level-playing field.


Best Regards
JOHN BIBBY aa42/MatheMagic
PS: Just been away. If any emails unanswered, please re-send..
1 Straylands Grove, York YO31 1EB (01904-330-334)

All statements are on behalf of aa42.com Limited, a company wholly owned by John Bibby and Shirley Bibby. See www.aa42.com/mathemagic and www.mathemagic.org


-----Original Message-----
From: big-chat@yahoogroups.com [mailto:big-chat@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Axel Hüttinger
Sent: 17 June 2007 12:30
To: big-chat@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [big-chat] We'll let museums charge admission again, say Tories

This might be interesting for the list:


We'll let museums charge admission again, say Tories

By SIMON WALTERS - More by this author »
Last updated at 10:51am on 17th June 2007

Comments Comments (25)



The Tories were at the centre of a fresh controversy after it was
revealed that they will scrap guaranteed free entry to top museums and
art galleries.

Shadow Culture Secretary Hugo Swire said his party would reverse
automatic free admissions introduced by Labour six years ago and allow
the attractions to restore entry charges.

He said that it would give museums more freedom over how to their run
their affairs and provide extra money to buy new paintings and exhibits
and improve facilities.

But Labour said the proposal would make it much harder for the less
well-off to have access to arts and culture. And they claimed it could
be the start of a whole raft of new Tory charges for public services.

*More....*

* Business displeasure as Cameron backs flexi hours for all parents

* Heseletine says Tories must restore 'power to the people'

* David Davis reignites grammar school row


"This would be a big mistake and a retrograde step,' Culture Secretary
Tessa Jowell told The Mail on Sunday.

"The policy of opening up museums and art galleries has hugely increased
visitor numbers, to the benefit of people from all classes and ages.

"David Cameron's party talks about wanting to be more inclusive and yet
they are promoting a policy that is a return to Thatcherism and would
exclude the less well-off."

Mr Swire told The Mail on Sunday: "We do not want to ban free
admissions, but we believe museums and galleries should have the right
to charge if they wish to. They could use the money to make their
facilities even better and could have special arrangements allowing
continued free access for children, students and others."

He said a Tory Government would restore Lottery funding to the arts,
which he said had been 'robbed' by Labour for other schemes.

And the Conservatives would set up a new 'national purchasing fund' -
with Government money - to buy new works of art.

The Conservatives are also considering abolishing targets set by Labour
for museums and galleries to attract more people from poor and ethnic
backgrounds.

They may be encouraged to return to concentrating on 'artistic excellence."

The introduction of free admission has seen the number of visitors to
large museums and galleries rise to a record 42million a year. Before
free entry, each visit could cost up to £25 for a family of four.

Attendances have boomed at the Victoria and Albert, the Natural History
and the Science Museum in South Kensington, London.

Visitors to Liverpool's eight national galleries have more than doubled.
The Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester and the National
Railway Museum in York have also thrived.

Prime-Minister-in-waiting Gordon Brown is firmly committed to retaining
free admissions to England's 24 national galleries and museums.

But Labour's scheme is not without its critics. Some museum directors
say the Government has not kept its promise to compensate them for loss
of income from entry fees.

And according to the Museums, Libraries and Archive Council, the middle
class still make up the majority of visitors to museums and galleries.
Part of the increased attendance could be the same people making more
visits, it says.

The British Museum and London's National Gallery, which have never
charged, have complained that the free entry policy resulted in some of
their funds being diverted to help others who had to drop charges.

--
Kurt Hüttinger GmbH
Mittelbügweg 90 - Schwaig bei Nürnberg - Germany
axel@huettinger.de
www.huettinger.de

Saturday, 27 October 2007

California fires

Why do all the recent California fires seem to stop at the Mexico border? Is the terrain so different - or are the Mexicans somehow in better control? (difficult to believe)

The fires that did NOT burn in Mexico may be like Sherlock Holmes's "dog that did not bark".)

It could be news blackout - 18 Mexicans died in the Gulf last week, but this seems to have been ignored (except briefly on BBC World Service).

In Wikipedia, references to this question and to the small number of fires in Mexico have been swiftly deleted by Americans.

The fact that the fires seem to have stopped at the Mexican border suggests that some at least were man-made, not natural.

Responses seem to have been characteristically brutal: one man was shot dead beacsue he was crouching and looked like he MAY have been starting a fire [http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,,2198866,00.html California police shoot dead suspected arsonist]

Citation: "The Los Angeles Times said state police were also involved in the shooting, but it was not clear which force fired the fatal shot. Lieutenant Scott Patterson, of San Bernardino police, told the newspaper: "We don't know whether he was an arsonist ...""